Timesizing®com - Homepage
[Commentary] © 2001-03 Philip Hyde, The Timesizing Wire™, Box 622 Cambridge MA 02143 USA (617) 623-8080

Makework Stories, Jan-Aug, 2003


8/28/2003  1 makework case - cited in Wall Street Journal (WSJ) &/or New York Times (NYT) or Boston Globe (BG) -

  1. Records: Halliburton has over $1.7B in Iraq contracts - Firm seen in position to earn more in reconstruction work, by Michael Dobbs, Washington Post via BG, A34, flagged by colleague Kate.
    [nooo kidding]
    WASHINGTON -...The company formerly [recently!] headed by VP Dick Cheney has 'won' [our quotes] contracts worth more than $1.7B out of Operation Iraqi Freedom
    [Ha, more like Operation Cheney Enrichment - for which YOUR kids are dying, you gulls!]
    and stands to make hundreds of millions more dollars under a no-bid contract awarded by the US Army Corps of Engineers, according to newly available documents.
    [Ah yes, the Corps of Engineers, another big makework center, and now apparently corrupted.]
    The size and scope of the government contracts awarded to Halliburton in connection with the [otherwise unnecessary] war in Iraq are significantly greater than previously disclosed....
8/27/2003  1 makework case - cited in Wall Street Journal (WSJ) &/or New York Times (NYT) -
  1. U.S. corn subsidies said to damage Mexico, by Elizabeth Becker, NYT, C4.
    [Not to mention the American taxpayer! -]
    WASHINGTON...- The more than $10 billion that American taxpayers give corn farmers every year in agricultural subsidies has helped destroy the livelihoods of millions of small Mexican farmers, according to a report to be released on Wednesday...by Oxfam International....
    [If Mexican farmers are our responsibility, so are farmers of every other nationality - or are we racist? The other huge damage is to the American diet, because subsidizing all the bloated executive 'compensation' of American agribusiness to grow corn corn corn and desperately turn much of it into corn syrup, wondrous to relate/mirabile dictu it finds its way into every single "food" produced in this grossly overweight country, and you can hardly find anything sugarfree to eat.]
8/26/2003  1 makework case - cited in Wall Street Journal (WSJ) &/or New York Times (NYT) -
  1. Tetra Tech Inc., NYT, C4.
    ...Pasadena CA, a provider of engineering and technical services...received a 1-year $65m contract from the U.S. military to check captured munitions and destroy selected items as part of the revitalization plan for postwar[?] Iraq.
    [Unspecified temporary "jobs."]
8/23-25/2003  9 makework cases - cited in Wall Street Journal (WSJ) &/or New York Times (NYT) -
  1. 8/23 Dying economy fuels exodus from America's heartland, by Hal Clifford, Boston Globe, A3, flagged by nurseryman Peter Bodycombe of Willseyville NY.
    America's population grew by 33m during the 1990s, but a visitor to most of the Great Plains could hardly tell the difference. Hundreds of rural counties, particularly in the Western farming states, have been losing population for the last 2 decades.
    [Same trend as in China, and similar cause -]
    The principal cause, say residents and specialists who study those areas, has been a lack of economic opportunities....
    [Translation: "it all comes down to (40-hr/wk) jobs."]
    Legislation introduced in Congress by Sen. Byron Dorgan (D- ND) is designed..\..to change that situation....
    [But with makework to pad out those obsolete 40-hour weeks, not simply a system to share the vanishing work.]
    The New Homestead Act proposes to stimulate job growth from the ground up [like anything from DC is 'ground up'!] by helping individuals start businesses or invest in rural areas. ...The bill would authorize investment tax credits of $1m per eligible county, allow accelerated depreciation of business investments, and create a $3 billion venture capital fund to invest in rural businesses....
    [Ain't it wunnerful how these high rollers always manage to justify more subsidies for the rich, when that policy, funneled via big agribusiness, is responsible for the concentration of income, lack of jobs and depopulation of the 'heartland' in the first place?! Unspecified, but probably not very many, new "jobs."]
    The average size of a farm..\..in places like Bottineau County ND...was 1,000 acres a generation [30 yrs] ago..\..said David Geiszler, chairman of the board of country commissioners...but now it is about 3,000 acres. That consolidation means fewer farm families and fewer opportunities for people to stay in the community..\..
    Another thrust of the legislation seeks to promote the growth of the professional class in rural areas by subsidizing higher education and home ownership. ...Provisions would forgive up to $2,000 per year of student loans for people who move into the counties, establish tax credits of up to $5,000 for home purchases, and allow homeowners to write off losses if their residences lose value.
    [Oh that'll be a BIG help - higher education already constituting one of our major realms of makework (see #19). And as for homes - weren't we focusing on JOBS, without which homes aren't much use?]
    The bill would also create "homestead accounts" to encourage individuals to save up to $2,500 annually, tax-free, and provide matching federal funds. The accounts could be used to pay for graduate studies, medical expenses, first-time home purchases, and business capital costs..\..
    [More and more backwards-bending big-government micromanagement. Aren't our rural areas afflicted enough with that kind of policy? Hasn't Byron 'Dork' Dorgan ever heard "he who governs least governs best," and "he who meddles, mars"?]
    The bill's provisions would apply to any rural county that has lost 10% or more of its population during the preceding 20 years....
    [Whoopee, there's a lotta jobs just digging that data!]
    This is the 2nd year the New Homestead Act [such a heart-warming name!] has been introduced. Congressional observers say it is not likely to be passed this session, either.
    [Thank God.]

  2. 8/23 The doctor's shrinking future, letter to editor by Dr. Marjorie Barnett of Silver Spring MD, NYT, A24.
    Re "Medical establishment turns to powerful allies to thwart residents' lawsuit" (news article, Aug. 18):
    When I was a resident in the 1980s, I supported long hours because I knew I could set up a private practice and earn a good salary.
    [As if you can't do that better without long hours.]
    Now the work is still emotionally rewarding, but for many doctors, it can take years to get back what they invest in training. Residents make far less per hour than other hospital workers, like nurses, but they have more education.... Doctors have become the handmaidens for insurance companies by accepting heavily discounted reimbursements and paying outrageous medical malpractice premiums....
    [Ah, the incredible private-sector makework of the American health-insurance chaos, oops, "system," which involves 3 times as much paperwork than the Canadian system - see 8/21/2003 #1.]

  3. [more private sector makework? -]
    8/25 Online today -...Real time, summary blurb, WSJ, front page.
    Why consumers are finding it harder than ever to figure out what kind of PC they should buy.
    [Could it be because PCs, originally quantity-enhancing technology, have become another area of quality-enhancing technology that is far far beyond quality levels that most people can even notice, let alone use? The desperation for work and income in a fixed-workweek economy rolls on. Compare -]
    8/25 Intel raised its revenue forecast, pointer summary (to column 5), WSJ, front page.
    ...citing demand for computers from U.S. consumers and buyers in Asia. But most corporate customers are refraining from major purchases or upgrades [because they've already got far more capability than they need?!], suggesting that a broad-based tech-sector recovery may be months or quarters away.

  4. 8/25 Boeing Co., Dow Jones via WSJ, B5.
    Japanese aircraft makers have asked the government to help fund their work in developing and building Boeing Co.'s 7E7 jet...nicknamed the "Dreamliner"..\..an industry organization said....
    [Shades of Paul Weaver's "The Suicidal Corporation" - always whining to government for taxpayer money. This is market economics??]

  5. 8/25 Indian industrial companies plan to expand, Dow Jones via WSJ, A9.
    ...Big government-funded infrastructure projects, cheap consumer loans and expectations of higher rural spending following a good monsoon are among the mix of factors that industry watchers say will fuel a boom in capital expenditure to increase output....
    [Again the assumption that "it's all about" capital expenditure alias investment - wrong - and output aka productivity (regardless of marketability) - wrong.]

  6. 8/24 Ask Marilyn -...Will life eventually stop getting more complex? question from Candy Welty of Baltimore MD & answer by Marilyn Vos Savant, Parade Mag, 6.
    I don't think so. And isn't it ironic? Consider the labor-saving devices that take so much time to learn how to operate.
    [Then they're not labor-saving, are they. They're just more desperate private-sector makework, to fill out those minimum 40-hour workweeks that we've had since 1940 before high-tech.]
    I have a TV and sound system that requires 6 remote controls. All I want to do is turn it on and off, and maybe adjust the volume or some other ordinary task. Sometimes I wish it had only a few little knobs.
    [Another area of technology that has 'advanced' to its point of diminishing returns.]
    And remember how the explosive growth of personal computers brought predictions of the "paperless office"? Well, I now buy 10 times as much paper as I did before!
    [Most of it will just pile and be a waste anyway (printing out emails to get them off your machine, Marilyn?) - and this ain't exactly great for the environment. Fixed-workweek economics and downsizing - leading to job desperation. Why will this come to an end? Anders Hayden's title gives the clue, "Sharing the Work, Sparing the Planet." We really don't have a choice. There is a worksharing imperative that is gradually materializing. We simply cannot sustain the alternatives - strained and bloating makework, or war.]

  7. 8/25 The aftermath of cyberattacks, pointer digest (to C4), NYT, C1.
    The 2 recent rogue computer programs, which disrupted corporate networks and forced PC users to take remedial measures - or ignore the problem at their peril - smell a lot more like vandalism than terrorism....
    [Virus writing and virus protection - private sector makework that demonstrates that our grasping technology has far outstripped our sharing technology, and our basis of common interest is weak and far behind. Also -]
    A nasty virus may not be over, pointer digest (to C4), NYT, C1.
    The fast-spreading SoBig.F e-mail virus is slowing after failing in an initial attempt to bog down the Internet, but security experts issued fresh warnings to computer users to brace for a possible new wave....

  8. 8/25 Bull S.A., the computer company, aims to emerge from dependence on France - In Europe, state subsidies are a contentious topic, by Victoria Shannon, NYT, C2.
    PARIS - Bull S.A., the computer company [has been] kept alive for decades with taxpayer money....

  9. 8/25 Senators say Iraq needs more U.S. troops and money, by Brian Knowlton, International Herald Tribune via NYT, A6.
    WASHINGTON...- Senior senators from both parties urged the Bush administration [yester]day to send 1000s more American troops to Iraq and said many billions more [taxpayer] dollars were needed to stabilize and rebuild that country and Afghanistan.... McCain.... Biden.... Graham.... [Compare -]
    U.S. said to plan bigger Afghan effort, stepping up aid, by David Rohde, NYT, A3.
    [Compare -]
    U.S. to send Iraqis to site in Hungary for police course - Will train up to 28,000 - Kerik says program is needed so security duties can be turned over quickly, by Dexter Filkins, NYT, front page.
    [Notice how the most important stuff is deepest in the paper. As we approach page one, it gets more and more trivial. But it's all makework.]

8/22/2003  3-in-1 makework case - cited in Wall Street Journal (WSJ) &/or New York Times (NYT) - 8/19/2003  1 makework case - cited in Wall Street Journal (WSJ) &/or New York Times (NYT) - 8/15/2003  1 makework case - cited in Wall Street Journal (WSJ) &/or New York Times (NYT) - 8/8/2003  1 makework case - cited in Wall Street Journal (WSJ) &/or New York Times (NYT) - 8/06/2003  1 makework case - cited in Wall Street Journal (WSJ) &/or New York Times (NYT) - 8/01/2003  2 outrageous makework cases - cited in Wall Street Journal (WSJ) &/or New York Times (NYT) -
  1. Bechtel Group, by Jackie Calmes, WSJ, A4.
    ...lead contractor on Iraq's infrastructure, now figures the price is at least $16B - more than 23 times the $680m the U.S. [taxpayer!] is so far contributing. Power and water will each take more than $6B; airports and building repairs will $2.6B. By 50% vs. 35%, poll respondents say U.S. hasn't kept war costs under control.
    [All for a totally irrelevant, completely unnecessary, invasion of a strange, weak country on the other side of the world. Vote for Bush-Cheney, America's hungry tapeworms!]

  2. Halliburton turns to a profit, aided by U.S.'s Iraq jobs, by Russell Gold, WSJ, B5.
    Halliburton Co.'s government contracts in Iraq boosted revenue in an otherwise poorly performing segment and helped swing the company to a $26m profit in the second quarter. The profit, equal to 6 cents a share, was a sharp reversal from a loss of $498m, or $1.15 a share, a year ago.
    [No wonder Cheney was desperate to shove American taxpayers into war - "War is declared - universal joy among the merchants!" We need to impeach this war criminal and his gang.]
    ...The Houston...oil-field services and construction company said work in Iraq, including a controversial no-bid contract to rebuild the postwar oil industry, contributed 9% of the quarter's total revenue....
    [The Bush administration is smashing America down far deeper and faster than any puny Osama bin Laden.]

7/18/2003  1 slightly reigned-in makework case - turned up in Wall Street Journal (WSJ) &/or New York Times (NYT) - 7/17/2003  2 makework cases - turned up in Wall Street Journal (WSJ) &/or New York Times (NYT) -
  1. California: Settling environmental case, AP via NYT, A20.
    The City of Oakland has agreed to pay $2 million to settle a case arising from the dispute arrest of two environmentalists who[m!] jurors ruled were wrongly accused of being "eco-terrorists" when their car exploded in 1990. The City Council decided not to appeal the case and agreed on Tuesday to settle after its legal fees in the 12-year-old case topped $4 million. The two, Darryl Cherney...and the late Judi Bari [all the more for Darryl!], of the group Earth First, were arrested by the Oakland police after the explosion. The case fell apart weeks later when prosecutors said there was not sufficient evidence to bring charges.
    [So let's see. Oakland now has to pay $6 million, whereas if it had settled immediately on this case of overzealous police, paranoid prosecutors and greedily imaginative lawyers, it would only have had to pay 1/3 of that. Well, Darryl in the photo is wearing a big smile. Truly the American Dream has become Hitting the Lottery or, as in this case, Suing the Deep Pocket. RIP Oakland taxpayers. Unspecified dragged-out government 'jobs', especially for lawyers, all those 2003-1990= 13 years, not just 12.]

  2. Sweden shows way [to makework], compiled by Don Clark, WSJ, B4.
    Swedes used to call their country Wireless Valley, due to thousands of mobile-technology start-ups and telecom powerhouse Telefon AB L.M. Ericcson. Over the past few years however, Ericsson has seen cellphone sales drop, cut its workforce nearly in half [see most recently 4/30/2003 #1]....
    Now Sweden's government is trying to renew some of the excitement. One weapon: a new Internet application for mobile phones, called MapMate. Developed by the National Land Survey, the Swedish government's 300-year-old mapmaking department, the service offers unusually quick and easy downloads of high-quality maps for handheld computers....
    [Unspecified prolonged government 'jobs' with accompanying imposition on taxpayers. There are certainly enough software map companies in the private-sector now to rebut the outdated claim that government involvement is needed. Compare the next article, "Paper chase," which starts, "Heard the old joke about the paperless office? It will arrive after the paperless bathroom." This is an outdated joke, what with the tremendous progress the Japanese have made toward just such paperless toilets. New toilets under brandnames like Toto have control panels that rival 747s'. They'll do everything for you - spraywash your posterior, blow-dry it etc. - except tie a bow around your butt. Colleague Kate sat a little too far forward once and it practically spraywashed the ceiling behind her! Lonely nerds no longer need Wendy the Blowup Plastic Girl or private rooms on the Internet - they can simply buy a Toto and emerge from la Petite Salle with smiles of satisfaction.]

7/16/2003  2 makework cases - turned up in Wall Street Journal (WSJ) &/or New York Times (NYT) -
  1. Rehiring initiative is extended to workers outside of ruling, Dow Jones via WSJ, C10.
    Verizon Communications Inc. is rehiring 1,100 laid-off workers in the Northeast who weren't covered by last week's order [see 7/12/2003 below] by an arbitrator to take back 2,300 employees in New York who were improperly dismissed in a cost-cutting initiative. The reinstatment possibly pre-empt[s] similar rulings in labor grievances in other states.... Arbitrator Shyam Das ruled Friday that Verizon's justification for the December layoffs - a weak economy and toughening competition from rivals and new technology [our italics] - wasn't permissable under \a\ union...contract covering 75,000 of the NY telephone company's nearly 230,000 employees.... "We disagree with that ruling," Verizon spokesman Eric Rabe said. "Now, we have voluntarily decided to no longer contest union grievances over layoffs in the other states. So we will rehire workers laid off in Pennsylvania, New Jersey and New England as well."
    [Just as well, if they want any markets left wherein to sell their wares and services. We suggest they wake up to the power of timesizing, not downsizing.]

  2. Government to study weight-loss successes, by Otesa Middleton, Dow Jones via WSJ, D4.
    WASHINGTON -...The National Institutes of Health this week announced a 3-year, 1,600-[participant] study to answer that question \of\ how to lose weight and keep it off....
    [Unspecified gov't 'jobs' propped up. Somehow in the last century, the federal government got into the diet business. The costly makework orientation of big government rolls on and on regardless of party in power.]

7/15/2003  2 makework cases - turned up in Wall Street Journal (WSJ) &/or New York Times (NYT) -
  1. North Korea will be paid, news blurb, WSJ, front page.
    ...$2.1 million by the U.S. to help conduct four searches for remains of U.S. servicemen missing since the Korean War.
    [This isn't makework for America. It's not even makework for an ally. This is makework for an enemy. What kind of ship is Bush and fellow CEOs running? He's already created the biggest national debt and annual deficit in history and he can't think of anything better to do with $2,000,000 than to pay a nuclear power with warheads pointed at us to search for soldiers that went missing in a war half a century ago??? As Jesus said, "Let the dead bury their dead and come, follow me" - whereupon he (Big J) went off healing the sick, of whom we in America are getting a lot more without health insurance every week.]

  2. [and France in North America has a leetle makework problem too -]
    On Bastille Day, far away but fervently French, by Clifford Strauss, NYT, A4.
    ISLES ST. PIERRE & MIQUELON - ...Forty percent of the people are on the government payroll..\..
    [Ouch. That rivals the Canadian north.]
    "We are very close to Canada [off southern Newfoundland], but we are more French than the French of France," the mayor of St. Pierre, Karine Claireaux, said....
    [Hey, so are half the Quebecois, and half the Anglo-Canucks are more British than the Brits.]

7/12/2003  1 unusual makework case, semi-saving 2300 jobs - turned up in New York Times (NYT) - 7/11/2003  1 makework case - turned up in Wall Street Journal (WSJ) &/or New York Times (NYT) - 7/10/2003  1 makework case - turned up in Wall Street Journal (WSJ) &/or New York Times (NYT) - 6/30/2003  1 makework case - turned up in Wall Street Journal (WSJ) &/or New York Times (NYT) - 6/24/2003  1 makework case - turned up in Wall Street Journal (WSJ) &/or New York Times (NYT) - 6/11/2003  1 makework case - turned up in Wall Street Journal (WSJ) &/or New York Times (NYT) - 4/4/2003  1 makework case - turned up in Wall Street Journal (WSJ) &/or New York Times (NYT) - 4/02/2003  1 makework case - turned up in Wall Street Journal (WSJ) &/or New York Times (NYT) - 3/14/2003  2 makework cases - turned up in Wall Street Journal (WSJ) &/or New York Times (NYT) -
  1. S.E.C. chief says fixing agency is going to take time - The new budget will allow the S.E.C. to increase its staff to 4,000 employees, (by Stephen Labaton,) NYT, C5.
    [Hoooboy, more and more enforcement cuz we got no common interest as Americans stronger than a money-drowned 1-person-1-vote "democracy" and dying-union-movement "seniority." No caps on "my share" of skills, work, income, wealth. So everybody out for hisself, cheatin, lyin, stretchin the quarterlies. No mechanism for recycling wasted excess skills, employment, income or wealth per person. Timesizing starts the recycling. Till then, we got more and more tax/debt-intensive makework.]

  2. [But since makework ain't enuf - always too little too late, we need systems like disability and shelters and prisons and military -]
    Cokes and candy for GI Joe - Consumer-goods companies vie to supply the military...., by Sarah Ellison, WSJ, B1.
    [Unspecified new jobs. And them's the nice jobs - the nasty ones are out there in the tents in the sand storms with Dubya-induced gas & germs comin' atcha. Den you gits to die to relieve the economy-killing officially-denied labor glut. You die an the rest of us gits a raise. Das de way it is. Cuz Dubya an de uddah rich boys too dumb to unleash de power o' sharework, not makework.]

2/20/2003  1 makework case, possibly getting undone - found in Wall Street Journal (WSJ) &/or New York Times (NYT) - 1/18/2003  1 makework case, with 10,000 new 'jobs,' found in Wall Street Journal (WSJ) &/or New York Times (NYT) -

For earlier makework stories, click on the desired date -

  • 2002.
  • 2001 & earlier.

    For more details, see our "social software" manual Timesizing, Not Downsizing, which is available online from *Amazon.com and at the Harvard Coop (3rd floor) in Harvard Square, Cambridge, Mass. 02138

    Questions, comments, feedback? Phone 617-623-8080 (Boston) or email us.


    Top | Homepage